Dynamic First Lady Abigail Adams

Abigail Adams (1744-1818), born Abigail Smith, was an early advocate for women’s rights in America through her extensive correspondence with her husband John Adams. Throughout her husband’s political career Abigail took on some roles that were traditional for women at the time and some that were not. Abigail was the second woman to serve as first lady and the first to occupy the executive mansion in Washington, D.C. She was also the first woman to become the wife and mother of U.S. presidents, though she did not live long enough to see her son John Quincy Adams get elected.

Abigail Smith was born on November 22, 1744, in Weymouth, Massachusetts—a farming community 14 miles southeast of Boston. Her parents, William and Elizabeth Smith, nicknamed her Nabby. Though she was small and frail as a child, Abigail was also stubborn. Abigail and her sisters did not go to school because the local ones were only for boys. Their father, who was the village parson, encouraged them instead to read from his extensive library. Abigail loved reading Shakespeare, Pope and Locke. The combination of her father’s encouragement and her love of reading made Abigail one of the best-read women of her time. Abigail’s mother Elizabeth disapproved of both her daughter’s stubbornness and her fondness for reading. She sent Abigail on visits to her maternal grandmother Elizabeth Quincy, who encouraged rather than corrected her granddaughter’s opinions.

John Adams and Abigail Smith met at a party when Abigail was fifteen. John was unimpressed by Abigail and her older sister Mary. He wrote that the Smith girls were “not fond, not frank, not candid.” Over time, John got to know Abigail better. He was basically forced into her company because his friend Richard Cranch courted Mary. At 17, Abigail was very attractive. She was tall and thin, with a dark complexion and dark hair and eyes. John was also impressed with her desire to learn. He brought Abigail books which they discussed. After a few years of courting, Abigail and John married on October 25, 1764, at William Smith’s parsonage. They moved into a cottage next door to John’s childhood home at Braintree.

The marriage was a love match as well as an intellectual one. Abigail said their hearts were “cast in the same mould [sic].” Abigail’s intelligence meant that they could converse on almost any topic. John recognized that his wife was the superior letter writer. “If I could write as well as you, it would be so, but, upon my word, I cannot.” 

Abigail Adams, Portrait by Benjamin Blyth, 1766

At the beginning of their marriage, Abigail was busy with traditional wifely duties such as caring for her children. Daughter Abigail (Nabby) was born in 1765, followed by John Quincy in 1767, Susanna in 1768 who died after one year, Charles in 1770 and Thomas in 1772. Abigail was responsible for the physical and moral well-being of her children while John worried about making more money on the circuit as a lawyer.

In June 1774 the Massachusetts legislature elected John to the Continental Congress. Abigail and John would be farther away from each other than ever. After John left for Philadelphia, Abigail confided that “the great anxiety I feel for my Country, for you and for our family renders the day tedious, and the night unpleasant.”

While John was gone, Abigail had even more responsibilities. For example, she made sure hired men on the farm did their jobs and she made decisions about harvesting crops. Abigail took so well to her farming tasks that a family friend said she “was like to outshine all the farmers.” In addition, Abigail saw to the children’s education. Dissatisfied with the schools around Braintree, she got a tutor for John Quincy. Abigail was also in some danger from the British who were quartered in Boston. John depended on her observations during the battles of 1775 and sometimes showed her letters to fellow delegates.

In the middle of all her other responsibilities, Abigail wrote John letters about women’s rights. She wrote: “I desire you would Remember the Ladies and be more generous and favorable to them than your ancestors. Do not put such unlimited power in the hands of the Husbands. Remember all men would be tyrants if they could. If particular care and attention is not paid to the Ladies, we are determined to foment a Rebellion, and will not hold ourselves bound by any laws in which we have no voice, or Representation.” In the eighteenth century, men had legal power over their wives. Women could not legally own property and some were in physically abusive marriages.

Abigail also wanted better education for women, who still did not attend school. She wrote, “If we mean to have Heroes, Statesman and Philosophers, we should have learned women.” John agreed on the education of women; after all, he married one of the most intelligent women of the time. He was not prepared to go any further for fear that everyone regardless of age, gender, or property ownership would demand equal rights. Independence from Britain would have to be won first.  

Before John returned from Philadelphia, Abigail received a letter stating that he was elected commissioner to France. John took ten-year-old John Quincy with him, leaving the Adams farm even lonelier for Abigail. Both she and John had a great sense of public duty, but the lack of reliable letters from her husband depressed Abigail. She wrote of her “cruel destiny” and herself “siting in my solitary chamber, the representative of the lonely love.”  

Despite her loneliness Abigail took on some unladylike pursuits on the home front. She managed the family finances. She acquired land when able and even started her own importation business. At first John sent her goods from France like handkerchiefs and linens that she consigned to her uncle. Later Abigail wrote to the merchants abroad herself and told them what she wanted. She used the profits for the taxes needed to fund the war or bartered for local goods.

By 1784 both John and Abigail were fed up with their separation and Abigail made plans to join John in Paris with Nabby. As a diplomat’s wife first in Paris and then in London, Abigail had a more public role to play in John’s career. She was expected to accompany him on all ceremonial and social occasions. Living in Europe gave Abigail an education in entertaining on a budget, since American diplomats were not paid as much as their European counterparts. She also managed to visit the wives of 15-20 government officials or foreign ministers each week.

Abigail and John returned home to Braintree in 1788, the same year that John was elected the first vice president of the United States. Abigail’s training in Europe helped her ease into the role of the vice president’s wife. She hosted a weekly levee, an open house where residents came and paid their respects. With time she managed to invite every senator and congressman to dinner.

After eight years as George Washington’s vice president, John was elected president in 1797. Before the election, Abigail worried about her ability to be as popular as Washington’s quieter wife Martha. “I have been so used to a freedom of sentiment that I know not how to place so many guards about me, as will be indispensable, to look at every word before I utter it, and to impose a silence upon myself, when I long to talk.” John thought she would do an excellent job and once elected, urged her to leave Massachusetts and come to him in Philadelphia.

As she had when John was vice president, Abigail organized her social routine as first lady, a term that had not been coined yet. The family ate breakfast together at 8am, and Abigail received visitors from 12-2 or 3pm. Dinner was at 3pm except on Tuesdays and Thursdays when she hosted company. After dinner she visited others. She was home by 7pm to spend time with family before an early bedtime. Abigail’s company dinners meant inviting 30-40 guests at a time. She could invite all the senators in one dinner but had a series of dinners for House members.

Her main complaint about entertaining came from a tradition George Washington started. On July 4th, all Congress and state officials were invited to the president’s residence. Washington was wealthier than the Adams family and Abigail resented the amount of cake, wine and punch she had to serve. She reported that guests ate 200 pounds of cake!

In addition to her traditional social duties, Abigail offered John political advice and helped promote his agenda. For example, she sent letters supportive of John’s presidential policies to friendly newspaper editors. Often these letters came from her son John Quincy. Abigail also received requests from office seekers asking her to influence John, many of which she answered.

Though mostly an asset to John’s work, Abigail erred in her support of the 1788 Alien and Sedition Acts. These laws permitted the arrest of newspaper editors publishing statements against the government and allowed the deportation of foreigners accused of seditious activities. Eager to protect her husband against the pro-French republican opposition led by Thomas Jefferson, Abigail was much more in favor of the acts than John. In fact, she wanted them to be harsher. She wrote that “they have had a salutary effect, weak as they are.” John later acknowledged that signing the acts was a mistake, but they remain a dark part of his legacy.

John and Abigail were the first president and first lady to move into the president’s house in Washington, D.C. Abigail was not impressed with the house since it was large and drafty. She described it as “a castle of a house” built “for ages to come.” In the meantime, it was impractical to live in. Abigail kept 13 fires going all day and used the east room to hang her laundry.

When John lost his bid for reelection, Abigail felt it keenly. She thought the public was ungrateful for John’s years of public service. Yet she was almost as busy in retirement as she had been as first lady. She had a house full of in-laws and grandchildren as well as some more distant relatives. Any family member who needed a place to stay was always welcome in John and Abigail’s home.

In 1814, one of Abigail’s sisters asked if she would marry John if she could live her life over. She responded, “Yet after half a century, I can say my first choice would be the same if I again had my youth and opportunity to make it.” On October 28, 1818, Abigail passed away surrounded by family including her beloved John.

Sources:       

Carlin, Diana B., Anita B. McBride, and Nancy Kegan Smith. U.S. First Ladies: Making History and Leaving Legacies. Cognella, Inc., 2024.

Ellis, Joseph J. First Family: Abigail and John Adams. Alfred A. Knopf, 2010.

Holton, Woody. Abigail Adams. Free Press, 2009.

Withey, Lynne. Dearest Friend: A Life of Abigail Adams. The Free Press, 1981.

Forgotten First Lady Ida McKinley

American First Lady Ida Saxon McKinley grew up in one of the wealthiest families in Canton, Ohio. Her father believed in women’s education, so Ida received a college degree. Yet he wanted his daughter’s education to be “more practical than ornamental.” As a result, Ida worked in her father’s bank, first as a teller and then as a manager. In addition to her work and college studies, Ida loved long walks, shopping, and going to concerts and the theater.

She met William McKinley at her father’s bank. Completely smitten, McKinley proposed in the fall of 1870. They had very different personalities, which some friends thought would be an obstacle. McKinley was reserved while Ida was impulsive and adventurous. Yet their love lasted throughout the years. A friend later said, “the relationship between them was one of those rare and beautiful things that live only in tradition.” The happy couple married in January 1871.

By Christmas, Ida gave birth to a daughter named Catherine. In fall of 1872 Ida was pregnant again, but both mother and daughter fell ill. Daughter Ida died of cholera after only five months. After this loss, Ida experienced a combination of symptoms, most notably epileptic seizures. McKinley was determined not to shut Ida up in a mental institution, though epilepsy was thought to be a psychiatric disorder. Unfortunately, more sadness followed. Their first daughter developed scarlet fever and died.

The loss of a second child nearly destroyed Ida, so McKinley offered to give up his political ambitions for her. Ida, however, wouldn’t hear of it. “I have no fear that your choice in life will leave you as you are in the things that make you dear to me,” Ida told him. With his wife’s encouragement, McKinley ran for Congress in 1876 and won.

Whether he was in Congress or home in Ohio, McKinley remained devoted to Ida. While in Congress, Ida sometimes called him out of meetings on trivial matters, such as his opinion on her clothes. When he left town for any reason, McKinley wrote letters to Ida that opened with “My own precious darling.”

Ida Saxon McKinley, unknown date

Ida’s health would sometimes improve for long stretches, and the couple took advantage of these times by traveling together. Ida loved to travel and managed two trips to California with her husband.

In 1897, William McKinley became president of the United States. Considering her illness, Ida might have given the duties of first lady to someone else, but she refused. Nevertheless, she had limitations. For example, Ida stood in receiving lines to greet White House guests but a chair was always placed behind her in case she became tired. She enjoyed hosting luncheons for members of Congress though she had to pace herself. Both she and McKinley wanted Ida to partake of society as much as possible despite her seizures. William Howard Taft remembered talking with them when he noticed “a peculiar hissing sound” coming from Ida. McKinley walked over to her, draped his handkerchief over her face, and continued the conversation.

Despite her limitations, Ida McKinley put her own stamp on the White House. She crocheted slippers which she gave to charities who them sold them at inflated prices. Her love of music and theater as a young woman continued during her time as first lady. Ida brought pop music like ragtime to White House social events. When she was well she attended comedies in Washington theaters and invited actors to the White House to discuss their craft. Unlike previous first ladies, she met with Susan B. Anthony and supported suffrage by speaking with suffrage organizations.

Though usually supportive of his career, Ida didn’t want McKinley to run for a second term as president. “I thought he had done enough for the country…and when his term expires he will come home and we will settle down quietly and he will belong to me,” Ida told a reporter. Her reasons for opposing a second term weren’t entirely selfish. Ida also feared that McKinley would be assassinated, since anarchists all over the world adopted assassination as a recent means of protest. McKinley refused to give up his reelection bid, however.

Sadly, Ida was right to worry. McKinley was shot, though his first concern was for Ida. “My wife–be careful how you tell her. Oh be careful,” McKinley told a secretary.

When Ida was told, she fainted but recovered quickly. She said, “Tell me all, keep nothing from me! I will be brave–yes, I will be brave for his sake!” Ida did as promised, comforting her husband with hardly any breakdowns. Others assumed the shock of the president’s death would instantly kill Ida, but it did not. At home in Canton, Ohio, she created a shrine to her husband. Ida McKinley passed away in 1907 at age 59.

Sources:

Merry, Robert. President McKinley: Architect of the American Century.

Miller, Scott. The President and the Assassin.

O’Brien, Cormac. Secret Lives of the First Ladies.

Forgotten First Lady Lucy Hayes

American First Lady Lucy Webb Hayes is most remembered as “Lemonade Lucy,” a nickname she received after banning alcohol from the White House. In fact, Lucy Hayes was much more than an advocate for abstinence.

Lucy was the first First Lady to graduate from college. She met Rutherford B. Hayes when she was a student at Ohio Wesleyan University, but at fifteen she was to young to be courted. Fortunately they met again in 1850 and married in 1852.

Despite her education, Lucy told Hayes that she thought she was “too light and trifling for you.” Hayes, though acknowledging his love for her, saw her as much more than a pretty face. He wrote in his diary, “Intellect she has too, a quick and spritely one, rather than a reflective and profound one. She sees at a glance what others study upon, but will not, perhaps, study what she is unable to see at a flash.”

Her college essays show that Lucy took a great interest in the issues of her time, including temperance and women’s rights. In one essay, Lucy compared men to women, with women coming out favorably. she wrote, “It is acknowledged by most persons that her (woman’s) mind is as strong as a man’s…Instead of being considered the slave of man, she is considered his equal in all things and his superior in others.”

Throughout their marriage, Lucy did not hesitate to share her opinions with her husband. An ardent abolitionist, she wrote to Hayes during the Civil War that President Lincoln was not doing enough to get rid of slavery. “The protection of slavery is costing us many precious lives,” she wrote. One of the lives she worried about was Hayes’s, since he was wounded more than once. Lucy traveled with Hayes, who was a Union officer, as much as she could during the war. She even brought two of their youngest children along, which may have contributed to their deaths before the age of two.

She developed an abiding interest in veteran’s causes as a result of her war experiences. When Hayes was elected governor of Ohio, Lucy established a soldier’s orphan’s home. Though she struggled to get the home funded, it became a state institution in 1870.

Lucy Hayes, circa 1877

In 1877, Hayes was narrowly elected President of the United States. Lucy’s excellent skills as a hostess helped her husband entertain both political parties at the White House. Her love of music led Lucy to invite vocalists and musicians to the White House. The first black opera singer Marie Selika sang arias in the Green room. On more informal occasions, guests were invited to sing gospel songs with the First Lady.

Though Lucy later took the blame for it, Hayes announced that alcohol would not be served at the White House after spring 1877. He may have partly been trying to please his wife, but Hayes also disliked the way male visitors behaved when drinking. Although some colleagues accused the First Couple of being stingy, they still entertained lavishly. During one dinner, hundreds of guests were treated to expensive foods like salmon, turkey and truffles, ham, lobster salads, and oysters among other dishes.

Since she had no social secretaries to help her entertain, Lucy invited young friends and family to the White House. Though she claimed she was getting an unfair reputation as a matchmaker, more than one politician met his future wife at one of the Hayes’s parties. Even the press acknowledged Lucy as a warm hostess. One reporter wrote of Lucy that “she is so vivacious and so responsive that everybody leaves her presence with a vague idea that he is the one person whom she was longing to see.” To most contemporaries, Lucy was known as a good conversationalist and hostess.

Lucy disappointed some women’s groups by not joining their causes. Despite the fact that the White House no longer served alcohol, Lucy never officially joined the Women’s Christian Temperance Union. She also remained neutral on women’s suffrage.

Lucy Hayes took a more traditional view of the role of First Lady, preferring to support her husband’s decisions rather than making public statements. Yet through her example of a college education and her private influence on issues, Lucy Hayes paved the way for more progressive First Ladies.

Sources:

Greer, Emily Apt. “Lucy Webb Hayes and Her Influence Upon Her Era.” https://www.rbhayes.org/hayes/lucy-webb-hayes-and-her-influence-upon-her-era/

Hoogenboom, Ari. Rutherford B. Hayes: Warrior and President.

O’Brien, Cormac. Secret Lives of the First Ladies.

Trefousse, Hans. Rutherford B. Hayes.

Edith Carow Roosevelt: Future First Lady

Official Portrait of First Lady Edith Roosevelt

Official Portrait of First Lady Edith Roosevelt

Although Edith Carow spent much of her childhood with Theodore Roosevelt and was best friends with Corrine Roosevelt, her family life and fortunes differed from theirs. During the Civil War, Edith’s father’s shipping business became less profitable. When he wasn’t away on business or drinking to forget his troubles, he doted on Edith. He told her tales of Sinbad the Sailor and instilled in her a love for literature that remained throughout her life.

Unfortunately, the shipping business remained unprofitable and the Carows had to depend on relatives. The family moved in with Edith’s aunt when Edith was a toddler. Her aunt’s home in New York was close to Theodore Roosevelt’s grandfather’s house, and Edith was soon welcomed into the Roosevelt circle. She was especially close to Corrine, Theodore’s younger sister, and adored Theodore as well. A sensitive child, Edith hid her broken toys whenever Corrine and Theodore came to her aunt’s house.

Theodore and Edith both loved books from an early age. Edith attended the home school taught by Theodore’s Aunt Gracie, and the two friends read everything they could, including the novels of Louisa May Alcott. Both the Roosevelt children and the adults treated Edith like part of the family, which relieved some of Edith’s anxiety as her alcoholic father went bankrupt and her mother succumbed to depression. Edith also spent time at the Roosevelt’s summer home, named Tranquility. The young friends recited their favorite poems during picnics and Theodore and Edith often danced together at parties.

After Theodore left for Harvard, Corrine and Edith started a literary society in which members contributed short stories and poems while other members critiqued them. Theodore hadn’t forgotten Edith, though. He invited his sisters, brother, and Edith to visit him during his freshman year. After Edith and his siblings left, Theodore told Corrine that he never saw “Edith looking prettier” and that everyone “admired her little Ladyship intensely, and she behaved as sweetly as she looked.”

When Theodore and Corrine’s father died, Edith spent time with both of them, and often went sailing with Theodore. On August 22, 1878, the two had a private conversation which neither ever discussed in public. It was clear that their relationship was damaged afterwards, however. By the winter, Theodore was engaged to Alice Lee. Edith did a good job of keeping her feelings to herself, though her friends noticed that she out-danced everyone at Theodore and Alice’s wedding.

Alice died after a difficult childbirth. Theodore was crushed, but he also instructed his sisters, who were still close to Edith, not to invite her over during his visits. He remembered the happy times they had together and feared he might still have feelings for her. However, they encountered each other one day in October of 1885 as Edith was leaving his sister Bamie’s house. Theodore and Edith, old friends and childhood sweethearts, secretly got engaged the following month.